James Wilson
2026-02-03
The image is ancient: a shepherd with a staff, watching over sheep, guiding them to good pasture and protecting them from danger. It's the image Jesus chose to describe His relationship with us and the role He entrusted to church leaders.
Pastoral care—the work of shepherding people through life's joys and sorrows, growth and setbacks—remains central to healthy church life. Yet it's one of the least taught, most learned-on-the-job aspects of ministry. Pastors often find themselves in hospital rooms, funeral homes, and crisis conversations with little formal training.
This guide explores what pastoral care looks like in practice, how to build sustainable care systems, and how to shepherd your congregation without losing yourself in the process.
Pastoral care is the ongoing attention given to the spiritual, emotional, and practical wellbeing of people in a church community. It's the work of knowing your people, walking with them through life's seasons, and helping them grow in faith and resilience.
This work takes many forms: a hospital visit to someone awaiting surgery, a counseling conversation with a struggling couple, a phone call to check on a grieving widow, a celebration of a young person's baptism. Some pastoral care is crisis response; much of it is ongoing relationship.
At its best, pastoral care isn't a program or department—it's a culture. It's the expectation that in this community, people are known and cared for. No one falls through the cracks unnoticed.
The biblical mandate is clear. Peter wrote to elders, "Be shepherds of God's flock that is under your care, watching over them—not because you must, but because you are willing, as God wants you to be" (1 Peter 5:2). Paul told the Ephesian elders, "Keep watch over yourselves and all the flock of which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers" (Acts 20:28).
Effective pastoral care includes several dimensions.
Sometimes the most powerful pastoral act is simply showing up. Being present during difficult moments—sitting in the hospital waiting room, attending the funeral, sharing a meal after bad news—communicates care that words alone cannot.
Presence doesn't require having the right thing to say. Often silence is more appropriate than speech. The ministry of presence is simply being there, bearing witness to someone's pain or joy, standing with them as a representative of Christ and His church.
Pastoral care requires deep listening—not just hearing words, but understanding the fears, hopes, and needs beneath them. This means asking open-ended questions, resisting the urge to fix or advise immediately, and creating space for people to process aloud.
Good pastoral listening suspends judgment, welcomes hard emotions, and conveys that the person matters. It's ministry in itself, not just a prelude to providing answers.
People often come to pastors for wisdom—about decisions, relationships, faith questions, or life direction. Pastoral guidance draws from Scripture, experience, and spiritual discernment to help people navigate complexity.
This isn't about telling people what to do. It's about walking alongside them as they seek God's direction, asking good questions, offering relevant Scripture, sharing perspective, and trusting them to discern. Guidance respects agency while providing support.
When people suffer, they need comfort before they need explanations. Pastoral care offers the comfort of God's presence, Scripture's promises, and human compassion.
This means acknowledging pain without minimizing it, grieving with those who grieve, and holding hope when they can't hold it themselves. Sometimes the pastor's role is simply to be a vessel for divine comfort in human form.
Pastoral care isn't only gentle. Sometimes it includes challenge—speaking truth that's hard to hear, calling people to repentance, addressing patterns of sin, or pushing toward growth.
Healthy challenge comes from relationship and earns the right to be heard. It's delivered with humility, motivated by love, and offered for the person's good rather than the pastor's sense of righteousness.
Different seasons of life require different pastoral approaches.
New Christians need grounding—basic theology, spiritual practices, community connection, and patient answers to many questions. Pastoral care for new believers often includes assigning mentors, inviting them into groups, and following up regularly during the critical early months.
They need protection too. New believers can be vulnerable to false teaching, predatory relationships, and burnout from doing too much too fast. Pastors watch over them with special attention.
Parents with young children face unique pressures: exhaustion, marriage strain, financial stress, and questions about raising kids in faith. Pastoral care addresses these practically—respite care, parenting resources, marriage support.
Access matters here. Young families often can't attend evening meetings. Flexible connection points help them stay engaged.
Single adults in churches designed for families can feel invisible. Good pastoral care includes them intentionally: don't assume everyone is married, create gatherings that aren't couple-focused, address singleness in preaching, and ensure singles have community and purpose.
Some singles want to marry; others are content. Pastoral care doesn't assume which is true but creates space for both.
When children leave, parents experience profound transition. Pastoral care acknowledges this season, helps people discover new purpose, and addresses the marital adjustments that often accompany it.
Empty nesters often have new capacity for service. Good pastoral care channels this toward meaningful ministry involvement.
As mobility decreases, pastoral care must go to people rather than expecting them to come to church. Regular visitation, communion brought to homes, connection maintained through calls and cards—these sustain people who can no longer attend in person.
Technology helps. Video calls, recorded sermons, and live-streamed services keep homebound members connected. But technology supplements rather than replaces personal presence.
Crisis can strike any life stage—job loss, divorce, diagnosis, death of a loved one, mental health crisis, prodigal child. These situations demand responsive pastoral care that addresses immediate needs while supporting long-term processing.
We'll address crisis ministry more fully below.
One pastor cannot provide adequate care for more than a few dozen people. As churches grow, care must be shared.
The math is simple. A pastor with 200 congregants who wants to have one meaningful conversation with each member quarterly needs to complete nearly 17 conversations per week—on top of sermon prep, leadership meetings, counseling, administration, and everything else.
Without a care team, one of two things happens: the pastor burns out, or people don't get cared for. Neither is acceptable.
The biblical model isn't a professional pastor doing all care while others watch. It's leaders "equipping the saints for works of ministry" (Ephesians 4:12). This means training church members to care for one another.
Lay caregivers can make hospital visits, bring meals, check on the grieving, facilitate support groups, and provide first-line care for many situations. This frees pastoral staff for situations requiring their particular expertise while distributing care across more people.
Training lay caregivers requires investment. Stephen Ministry is one well-known model—a 50-hour training program that prepares laypeople for one-to-one care. Other churches develop their own training tracks.
Key topics include: listening skills, confidentiality, boundaries, when to refer, basic crisis response, and spiritual care basics. Ongoing supervision ensures quality and supports the caregivers themselves.
In many traditions, deacons bear specific responsibility for congregational care. Recruiting and training deacons for this work extends pastoral care capacity significantly.
Deacons might be assigned geographic zones or subgroups of the congregation. They maintain regular contact, notice when someone is missing, respond to needs, and escalate to pastors when necessary.
When small groups function well, they become front-line care networks. Group members notice when someone struggles, provide practical help, and sustain ongoing relationship.
This requires group leaders trained in basic care and clear expectations that groups are pastoral, not just social or educational.
Crisis reveals the importance of pastoral care. When life falls apart, people need their church.
Death is the most common pastoral care crisis. When a church member dies—or when their loved one dies—pastors respond with presence, practical help, and spiritual support.
Immediate response matters. Being available within hours of a death, even just to sit with the family, communicates care that a delayed response cannot. If you can't be there immediately, ensure someone from the church is.
Funeral planning is pastoral care. Helping families create a meaningful service that honors their loved one while proclaiming gospel hope is a significant ministry. Take time to learn the deceased's story, involve family in planning, and craft something personal rather than generic.
Grief follow-up often gets neglected. Everyone shows up in the first week; few remain at the three-month mark when grief hits hard. Build systems for ongoing contact with the grieving—check-in calls, card reminders, anniversary acknowledgment.
Serious illness, accident, or frightening diagnosis creates crisis. Pastoral care includes hospital visits, family support, practical help (meals, childcare, transportation), and spiritual presence through uncertainty.
Hospital visitation is an art. Go when you're wanted. Keep visits brief unless otherwise indicated. Focus on presence, not preaching. Pray before you leave. Coordinate with medical staff as appropriate.
When couples come for help, they're often already in trouble. Some marriages can be restored; some cannot. The pastor's role is to care for both spouses, point toward reconciliation where possible, and help people navigate what comes next.
Know your limits. Most pastors aren't trained marriage therapists. Develop referral relationships with licensed counselors for situations beyond your competence. Making a referral isn't failure—it's wisdom.
When marriages end despite best efforts, continue caring for both parties and help the church community navigate the awkwardness.
Suicidal ideation, psychotic episodes, severe depression, and other mental health crises require careful response. Pastoral care provides spiritual support but doesn't replace professional mental health care.
Know the warning signs of suicide: talking about death, giving away possessions, sudden calm after depression, acquiring means, saying goodbye. Take all mentions of suicide seriously. Ask directly: "Are you thinking about hurting yourself?" Asking doesn't plant the idea; it opens the door to help.
Have referral resources ready. Know local crisis hotlines, emergency procedures, and trusted mental health professionals. In acute crisis, stay with the person and facilitate professional help.
Job loss, bankruptcy, or financial devastation is spiritual crisis too. Pastoral care addresses both practical needs (benevolence funds, financial counseling, job networking) and spiritual needs (identity beyond work, trust amid uncertainty, community support).
Benevolence requires wisdom. Help people while maintaining dignity. Set clear policies so decisions aren't arbitrary. Involve others in discernment to avoid both excessive giving and excessive stinginess.
You can't care for what you don't know about. Systems for identifying and tracking care needs make pastoral care more effective.
How do care needs surface? Some people ask directly; many don't. Create multiple entry points: connection cards, prayer requests, small group reports, staff observation, and congregant referrals.
Train the whole church to surface needs. Teach members to notify the church when someone is hospitalized, struggling, or celebrating. Make it easy to report needs through your church management system.
Tracking who's being cared for, by whom, and what follow-up is needed prevents things from slipping through cracks. Simple spreadsheets can work, but dedicated church management tools provide better tracking.
Look for systems that allow logging pastoral interactions and outcomes, assigning follow-up tasks with due dates, viewing a member's care history, generating reports on care activities, and integrating with broader member records.
Platforms like MosesTab include care tracking alongside member management, giving, and communication—keeping all pastoral information connected rather than siloed.
Care tracking raises privacy concerns. Not everyone on staff needs to know everything. Set appropriate access controls. Train everyone who sees care records in confidentiality. Know what can be shared and what cannot.
Some information should never be in electronic records—confessions that could harm if discovered, legal matters, situations where digital trail creates risk. Use judgment.
Pastoral care givers need care too. Ministry burnout is epidemic, and sustained neglect of personal wellbeing catches up eventually.
Compassion fatigue—the emotional exhaustion of caring for suffering people—affects pastors profoundly. Signs include emotional numbness, cynicism, difficulty sleeping, reduced empathy, and dreading care situations.
Prevention requires boundaries—sustainable limits on availability and investment. You cannot pour from an empty cup. Rest, recreation, relationships outside ministry, and genuine Sabbath are not luxuries but necessities.
Healthy pastoral care requires boundaries that protect both pastor and congregant.
Availability boundaries mean you're not always on call. Define times when you respond to non-emergencies and times when you don't. Use voicemail, communicate expectations, and protect family and rest time.
Emotional boundaries mean you care without carrying. You can enter someone's pain without making it your own. Clergy therapy or spiritual direction helps process what you absorb in ministry.
Physical boundaries mean maintaining appropriate distance, especially in one-to-one settings. Meet in visible places. Avoid situations that could be misinterpreted or could become inappropriate.
Pastors aren't omnicompetent. Recognizing when a situation requires professional help is wisdom, not weakness.
Refer to counselors for: clinical mental health issues, complex trauma, situations requiring therapeutic techniques beyond your training.
Refer to specialists for: legal matters, financial planning, medical questions, addiction recovery.
Refer to other resources for: support groups, specialized ministries, community services.
Build a referral network. Know trusted Christian counselors, lawyers, financial advisors, and community resources. Making a warm referral—personally connecting someone to a resource—is more effective than handing out a phone number.
How do you know if your care systems are working?
Quantitative measures include: Number of pastoral visits made, response time to crisis notifications, percentage of congregation in small groups, number of trained lay caregivers, and follow-up completion rates.
Qualitative measures include: Congregational satisfaction surveys, feedback from those who've received care, stories of care well given, and staff assessment of blind spots.
What you measure shapes what happens. If you only count preaching and attendance, care gets neglected. Include care metrics in how you evaluate church health.
Beyond systems and programs, the goal is a culture where care is woven into congregational DNA.
Preach on one-another passages: "Carry each other's burdens" (Galatians 6:2), "Be kind and compassionate to one another" (Ephesians 4:32), "Encourage one another daily" (Hebrews 3:13). When care is taught biblically, people understand it as discipleship, not just niceness.
Highlight examples. When congregation members care for each other well, celebrate it (with permission). Stories shape culture more than exhortations.
What leaders do matters more than what they say. When pastors are present in crisis, when elders visit the sick, when staff remember names and situations—this models care that permeates the church.
Conversely, distant, inaccessible leadership teaches that care isn't important. Lead from among the people, not above them.
Make care easy. Clear processes for reporting needs, accessible ways to request prayer, simple paths to volunteer for care ministry—these lower barriers to both giving and receiving care.
Your church management system should support this. Member records that include care notes, communication tools that enable outreach, reporting that tracks follow-up—technology serves care when implemented well.
How do I balance pastoral care with other ministry responsibilities? Build teams and systems that distribute care. Your role shifts from providing all care yourself to equipping others, responding to complex situations, and ensuring the system works. Protect time for care even amid administrative demands—it's not optional but central to pastoral identity.
What do I say when I don't know what to say? Often the honest answer is best: "I don't know what to say, but I'm here with you." Presence matters more than words. Avoid clichés that minimize pain ("Everything happens for a reason"). Sometimes silence is ministry.
How do I handle confidentiality when someone tells me something I think I should share? Generally, maintain confidentiality. Exceptions include: imminent danger to self or others, abuse of children or vulnerable adults, and situations where the person gives permission to share. Know your state's mandatory reporting laws. When in doubt, consult without sharing identifying details.
How do I care for people I find difficult to like? Pastoral care isn't based on affection but commitment. Pray for grace. Look for the image of God in difficult people. Maintain professional care even without personal warmth. It's okay to involve others when personality conflicts make your care less effective.
What if I'm struggling and need pastoral care myself? Seek it outside your congregation when possible—a therapist, spiritual director, or pastor friend. Your congregation needs you healthy, and getting care is stewardship of the gift you are to them. Don't try to shepherd others while ignoring your own wounds.
What aspects of pastoral care does your church do well? Where do you see room for growth? Share in the comments.
Senior pastor with 20 years of ministry experience across churches of various sizes. James is passionate about equipping pastors to care for their congregations with both competence and compassion.
Get the latest church leadership insights delivered to your inbox.
52% of growing churches prioritize small groups. Learn how to launch, grow, and multiply small groups that transform your congregation into authentic community.
24% of regular attendees now volunteer weekly—up from 15% in 2024. Learn proven scheduling strategies, avoid burnout, and build a thriving volunteer culture.
Transform your church's worship experience through strategic music ministry development, team building, and technical excellence.